I just reviewed 286 Job Applications

I just reviewed 286 job applications for a role I needed to fill. Yep, that’s right. Every single one.

LinkedIN is full of horror stories from job hunters. It’s time for a change. I don’t know if this is it, but I felt I needed to do something different.

And I’m glad I did.

Not because I'm a sucker for punishment. But because behind each CV and cover letter was someone who took the time to apply, so the least I could do was give them the same attention in return.

Buried in the details were small but meaningful signs - a specific achievement, a phrase that showed grit, a side project that revealed passion. Things no algorithm would catch. Things that tipped the scales.

Sure, I used AI. But as my assistant, not my decision-maker.

Here’s how:

  • Promotion via LinkedIN

  • Human brain for longlist (and yes, I actually notified the no’s)

  • ChatGPT to build interview questions and scoring framework

  • Cal.com for scheduling 30-min chemistry calls

  • Otter.ai to record conversations

  • ChatGPT to analyze transcripts against the framework (to back up my gut)

  • Human judgment for the final cut

The kicker? Attitude trumped everything. You can teach skills. You can't teach giving a damn.

And four observation for job seekers:

  • Make it easy for us to say yes, rather than no. Bring outcomes and key achievements to the top.

  • Stand out or stand aside. Many had more creative CV formats (this was a Content/Social Media role, so made sense). Guess who got noticed?

  • Typos = instant death. If you can't be bothered to spellcheck, why should I trust you with our brand?

  • Use AI to enhance, not replace. I expect you to use it. But total AI generation? You can smell it a mile off.

Here's the thing: in our rush to automate everything, we've forgotten that hiring is fundamentally human. It's not about efficiency at the expense of connection. It's about using efficiency to create MORE connection.